Atheism

July 25, 2007

How to handle an angry atheist

Martin Marty, astute observer of culture and religion, has some great suggestions in The Christian Century on how to respond to best-selling authors such as Hitchens and Dawkins. 

Many of us are tempted to roll the eye at their claim that religion is the poisonous source of all evil, but the wise Dr. Marty advises, "Don't sneer. Where does that get us?" 

"Converse, don't argue," he adds, saying no one wins arguments about the existence of God. Instead, enter into dialogue and pose some good questions.

"Agree with the authors that in the name of religion horrible things have been done and are being done." In other words, 'fess up to the facts. Transparency and humility can be powerfully disarming.

"Don't sound triumphalist" by reminding them that we outnumber them 97-3. Such a nyah-nyah attitude raise our own comfort level, "but what does it prove?" Dr. Marty asks.

OK. Just one more.

"Read better books by these authors," Dr. Marty says, "as opposed to their sensational polemics on a subject they are not well versed in." Don't write off their other offerings just because of their rant on religion -- we just might learn something.

Preach on, Brother Marty!

Featured Bloggers

  • Gen-X Rising
    Andrew Thompson's award-winning column in the United Methodist Reporter inspired this blog of the same name.
  • Five Practices
    Bishop Robert Schnase (Missouri Area) began blogging to encourage discussion around living out the practices he outlines in his 2007 book.
  • The Methoblog
    A cooperative community of blogging United Methodist laity and clergy, inviting conversation on faith, theology, and all things Methodist.
  • Questing Parson
    Being retired doesn't always mean you stop serving a congregation. Or the blogosphere. Guy Kent has a lot of serving, preaching and teaching left in him yet.
  • Reflections on Aging Well
    The blog of author Missy Buchanan, who writes Aging Well, a regular column in the United Methodist Reporter.
  • A United Methodist Emerging
    Susan Cox-Johnson is a rarity: a blogging District Superintendent. She serves in the Missouri Annual Conference.
  • In the Open Space: God and Culture
    At her blog, Carmen Andres posts her thoughts about God and faith as she sifts through culture, events and church-talk.
  • Congo Missions - Mulungwishi
    David and Lori are United Methodist missionaries to the Democratic Republic of Congo.